Simple Deluxe 20 Inch Hardside Carry-On Review: Good Fit, 19 Ratings

  • Published at 13 by 9 by 21.5 inches, inside the commonly cited guideline on height and width and exactly at the limit on depth, with no statement on whether wheels are included.
  • The 2,515.5 cubic inch capacity is exactly the three exterior dimensions multiplied together, not usable interior space; expect nearer 31 to 33 liters.
  • Double spinner casters stated explicitly, which spread load better than single ones, on an ABS shell at a light 6 pounds.
  • Wet and dry mesh areas with X securing straps, a better interior than several pricier cases in this catalog.
  • No warranty and only 19 ratings; the department and model number fields contain truncated product name text rather than data.
SKU: B0DS5GGXWH Category:

Description

Who this Simple Deluxe case suits

This is a cheap ABS hard shell in the 20 inch class with double spinner wheels, a built in TSA lock, an expansion and a wet and dry divided interior. The buyer is the occasional traveler who wants a rigid cabin case at a low price and does not need a brand name on it.

The trip is three to five nights. The specification is short and mostly reasonable, and the main caution is the review base, which is very small. Comparable cheap hard shells with far more accumulated buyer experience include the Travelers Club Chicago hardside spinner and the Travelhouse hardshell carry on.

Dimensions, and a case that fits

The specification block gives 13 by 9 by 21.5 inches, and a feature bullet publishes the same figures alongside the two larger sizes in the family: 15.5 by 10.5 by 25 inches for the 24 inch case and 18 by 12 by 29.5 inches for the 28 inch. Two independent sources agreeing on this size is worth crediting.

Against the size guideline most commonly cited for United States domestic cabin baggage, roughly 22 by 14 by 9 inches, this case is inside on height at 21.5, comfortably inside on width at 13, and exactly at the limit on depth at 9. That is a good position, better than most of the hard shells in this batch, and it is the practical argument for the case.

What the listing does not settle

Whether the double spinner casters and the retracted handle are included in the 21.5 inch height. On a hard shell the casters bolt outside the shell, so if 21.5 is a shell figure the object a gate agent measures is taller, and the half inch of margin disappears quickly. Nothing on the listing says either way.

We will not write that this case is airline approved and the listing does not claim it. Check the allowance published by the carrier and fare you booked, note that budget and regional carriers are frequently stricter than the majors and that many international carriers add a cabin weight limit, and measure the case on arrival.

The case is expandable and no expansion figure is published anywhere. Whatever it adds goes onto a depth that is already exactly at the commonly cited 9 inch limit, so expanded this case is outside the guideline. Use the expansion on legs where the case goes in the hold, and close it before you approach a gate.

Shell, wheels, handle and lock

The shell is ABS, named plainly, with a scratch resistant surface. ABS is the lightest of the common luggage polymers, which is why the case weighs 6 pounds, and the most brittle. Under a hard impact it stars and cracks at a corner rather than flexing and returning to shape the way polycarbonate does. The listing calls it durable and sturdy with dependable strength, which is fair relative to a fabric bag and optimistic relative to polycarbonate. Keep the case in the cabin and it will last; check it every month and the corners are where it ends.

The scratch resistant surface is worth having, because a bare gloss hard shell picks up visible marks on its first trip and never loses them.

The wheels are double spinner casters, stated explicitly, which many listings at this price will not do. Two wheels per mount spread the load and resist the sideways shear that snaps a single caster, so double casters are the more durable arrangement. The general spinner trade still applies: they roll sideways easily on smooth terminal floors, catch and tip on curbs and cobblestone, and exposed casters remain the most common failure point on any wheeled case. No wheel material or bearing detail is published.

The handle is described only as retractable. No stage count, no extended height, no tube material.

A built in TSA lock is fitted, keyless. The listing says it ensures the belongings in your carry on stay safe. It does not. A TSA lock exists so a screener can open the case with a master key rather than cutting it, and those master keys have circulated widely for years. It is a deterrent against a casual hand and a way to stop the case falling open, and the zipper it sits on can be split with a ballpoint pen and closed again by running the sliders across the split. Keep passports, cash and electronics on your person.

The interior is a spacious main compartment with wet and dry mesh areas and X shaped securing straps. Separating damp things from clean clothes is the single most useful piece of organization in any case, and X straps hold a packed half down when the shell is opened flat. For a case at this price that is a better interior than several more expensive ones in this batch.

Capacity, weight and a figure that is only arithmetic

Capacity is published as 2,515.5 cubic inches, which is an unusual unit and works out to roughly 41.2 liters. Run the multiplication on the published exterior of 13 by 9 by 21.5 inches and you get 2,515.5 cubic inches exactly.

The two numbers are identical because the capacity figure is the three exterior dimensions multiplied together, not a measurement of what fits inside. A rigid hard shell typically loses a fifth to a quarter of its envelope to the shell walls, the handle channel and the internal wheel wells, which would put realistic usable capacity nearer 31 to 33 liters closed. Plan from the linear dimensions, and note that anyone comparing this case against a rival quoting genuine usable liters is not comparing like with like.

Weight is 6 pounds, published consistently in two fields. Six pounds is light for a rigid cabin case with a built in lock and an expansion mechanism, and about a pound under several branded polycarbonate shells. On United States domestic routes cabin bags are not weighed. On budget European and many Asian carriers, where the allowance is 7 or 8 kilograms and enforced at check in, six empty pounds takes roughly half of it before you pack.

Data quality, warranty and the review base

Two fields on this listing contain product name text rather than data. The department field reads 20 Inch Hardside Carry On Luggage, Suitcase with, cut off mid sentence, and the item model number field carries a similar fragment. The product description is also just the product title repeated, so it adds nothing. Those are source data artifacts rather than product defects, but they tell you how carefully this listing is maintained, and they are the reason to verify the dimensions yourself rather than trusting the page.

No warranty term appears anywhere on this listing. No period, no coverage description, no exclusions, and nothing about airline handling damage, which is the standard exclusion in luggage coverage and the damage that actually occurs. At this price that silence is normal and it is what you are pricing in: you are buying a case, not a repair commitment.

The review base is the real caution. The listing carries 4.5 from 19 ratings with a rank of 109th in its Amazon carry on luggage category. Nineteen ratings is not enough to tell you anything about durability. A high average across nineteen buyers means the first nineteen were pleased, not that the casters survive two years, and with no warranty published there is nothing else to fall back on.

If longevity matters more than price, buy something with thousands of reports behind it instead. The Chicago case linked above carries more than 34,000 ratings, and the GOODLUGG 20 inch ABS carry on is another light ABS option in the same bracket. The wider field is in our carry-on luggage and suitcases sections.

Who should buy it and who should not

Buy it if you want a light, cheap rigid cabin case whose published dimensions sit inside the common guideline, with double casters, a wet and dry divided interior and a lock included. Those are sensible choices at this price and the dimension data is consistent across two sources. Skip it if you need a body of durability evidence before buying, because there are 19 ratings, and skip it if the case will be checked regularly, because ABS cracks where polycarbonate flexes. Do not plan around 41 liters: that figure is the outside of the case multiplied out, and there is no published expansion figure at all.