Rockland Safari F191-CAMO 20-Inch Hardside Spinner Review

  • A 20 inch hard shell on multi directional double spinner castors with a chrome telescoping handle and no expansion gusset.
  • Published as 22 by 13.5 by 9 inches with wheels by all three sources on the page, which fits inside the commonly cited 22 by 14 by 9 allowance.
  • The shell is described as a polycarbonate and ABS blend in one place and as polycarbonate in another, which changes how the case fails under impact.
  • Weight is given as 6.5 pounds in the description and 3.18 kilograms, or 7.01 pounds, in the attributes, and the capacity field reads 65 pounds.
  • Rockland states a five year warranty, and a maker bullet names five specific airlines whose size restrictions the case is said to meet.
SKU: B00DQRQYZY Category:

Description

The Rockland Safari is a 20 inch hard shell in a camouflage finish on double spinner castors, and it is one of the few cases in this batch whose published with wheels dimension actually fits inside the commonly cited United States domestic cabin allowance. It also names five specific airlines it is said to meet, publishes a five year warranty, and contradicts itself on both the shell material and the empty weight.

The traveler and the trip

Around 38 liters at six and a half to seven pounds is a three to four day bag for one adult. The camouflage finish is doing genuine work: identifying your case quickly on a carousel is worth more than most buyers credit, and a patterned shell also hides the scuffing that a plain gloss shell shows within a trip.

The buyer is the occasional flyer or the household that wants a distinctive second case. It is not a bag for someone who flies weekly, for reasons covered below. Frequent travelers should look at cases with a fully specified polycarbonate shell, and the Samsonite Omni PC is the direct comparison. The wider field sits in carry on luggage.

Dimensions, and a figure that clears the bar

Both the product description and the first manufacturer bullet give 22 by 13.5 by 9 inches with wheels. The attribute block gives 13.5 by 9 by 22 inches, the same measurement in a different order. For once every source on the page agrees, which is rare in this catalog and worth crediting.

Against the common allowance

An airport sizer measures the case standing on its castors, so the with wheels figure is the right one to use. The commonly cited United States domestic carry on allowance is around 22 by 14 by 9 inches. This case matches the height exactly at 22 inches, has half an inch of margin on width, and matches the depth exactly at 9 inches. It fits, on the maker’s own numbers.

The margins are thin, though. Matching two of three axes exactly leaves nothing for a gauge that is fractionally tight or a castor that stands slightly proud of the quoted figure, and a rigid shell cannot be compressed. The half inch of width is the only real slack.

A manufacturer bullet says the carry on meets the size restrictions of United, American, Delta, Southwest and Allegiant. Naming specific carriers is a scoped claim and it is considerably more honest than the airline approved language elsewhere in this catalog, because it can at least be checked. It is still the maker’s claim and it covers five airlines rather than all of them. Budget and regional carriers publish tighter allowances than the mainstream figure, and international carriers frequently add a cabin bag weight limit. We are not going to write that this bag is airline approved. Check your own carrier and fare.

Nothing in this listing describes an expansion gusset, and the absence of one is quietly in the buyer’s favor: a case that cannot expand cannot be talked into a non compliant size at a gate.

The shell material, and the contradiction

The product description says the case is made of polycarbonate and ABS. A manufacturer bullet says lightweight yet extremely durable polycarbonate material, with no mention of ABS. Those are materially different claims.

Pure polycarbonate deforms under a crush load and springs back rather than cracking, keeps rain out entirely, and does not go brittle in a cold hold. ABS is stiffer, cheaper and the most brittle of the common shell polymers, cracking under impact where polycarbonate flexes. A blend sits between the two: better than pure ABS, short of pure polycarbonate, and priced accordingly. Given that this case sits at Rockland’s price point, the blend described in the product description is the more plausible answer, and the bullet claiming pure polycarbonate is the one to treat with caution. Ask the seller, because this determines how the case fails.

Worth noting that Rockland’s other cases in this catalog, including the Rockland London and the grey London listing, are described as plain ABS. If this one really is a polycarbonate blend, it is a step up within the range.

Wheels, handle and interior

The wheels are multi directional double spinner castors rotating 360 degrees. Dual castors are the right choice and they roll noticeably better under a full load than single wheels, and they are more stable on a sloped floor. They remain the first thing to fail on any budget case, because the castor housing is riveted to a thin shell wall and there is not much material holding it. Spinners are poor on cobble and gravel, and their exposed profile is part of why the depth sits at the full 9 inches.

The handle is an internal chrome telescoping unit with a push button release. Chrome plated steel is heavier than aluminum and not obviously better, and the listing does not say how many stop heights it offers.

Inside there is a mesh zip pocket and an elastic pocket. That is minimal but honest for the money. There is no divider mentioned, so one half of the case is open when it lies flat, and there is no lock of any kind. The absence of a lock is not the failing it might sound like, since a TSA recognized lock opens to a universal screener key and secures nothing of value, but it does mean the zipper can be opened by anyone who picks the case up. Cases at a similar level with compression straps and dividers, such as the Rockland Melbourne, are worth comparing on that basis.

Capacity, weight and two broken numbers

The total capacity field gives 38.3 liters, which is a plausible figure for a 22 by 13.5 by 9 inch shell once the wall thickness and the retracted handle housing are subtracted. That is the usable number.

The capacity field gives 65 pounds. Pounds is not a unit of volume, so that figure is either a maximum load rating that has landed in the wrong field or a straightforward import error. Disregard it.

The weight is contradictory too. The product description says the case weighs 6.5 pounds. The attribute block says 3.18 kilograms, which is 7.01 pounds. That is half a pound apart and the listing does not reconcile it. Half a pound is not much in absolute terms, but on carriers that enforce a cabin bag weight limit it is half a pound of clothing, and it is another instance of a listing that cannot agree with itself.

Note also that the manufacturer field reads Fox Luggage rather than Rockland. That is a corporate arrangement rather than an error, and it appears across every Rockland listing in this catalog.

Warranty and the comparison set

Rockland publishes a five year warranty in the product description. That is longer than many budget hard shells offer and shorter than the ten year limited terms on premium polycarbonate cases. It is a real stated term and it puts this listing ahead of the many in this batch that publish none.

As with every luggage warranty in this category, expect it to cover defects in materials and workmanship rather than airline handling damage. Handling damage is the damage that actually happens to a checked bag, and a warranty silent on it should be read as excluding it. Ask for the terms in writing before you rely on them. Travelpro’s limited lifetime term is the only one in this catalog that explicitly covers carrier damage, for one year after registration. Larger cases in the same construction sit under suitcases.

Who should buy it and who should not

Buy it if you want a distinctive hard shell that actually fits a 22 by 14 by 9 box on the maker’s own numbers, with dual castors, no expansion gusset to get you into trouble, and a stated five year warranty. On dimensional honesty this is one of the better listings in the batch.

Skip it if you need to know what the shell is made of, because the description says a polycarbonate and ABS blend and the bullet says polycarbonate. Skip it too if you need an exact weight before ordering, since the page publishes both 6.5 pounds and 7.01 pounds. And treat the list of five named airlines as the maker’s claim covering five carriers, not as approval anywhere else.

Additional information

Product Dimensions

13.5 x 9 x 22 inches

Item Weight

3.18 Kilograms

Department

unisex-adult

Manufacturer

Fox Luggage

Country of Origin

China

Item model number

F191-CAMO

Capacity

65 Pounds

Capacity Total

38.3 Liters